Purpose: This reflection guide is designed to help tutoring programs intentionally build and sustain strong, academically focused student-tutor relationships as a core driver of program success. High-impact tutoring is most effective when students feel deeply connected to their tutors—when respect, trust, confidence, motivation, and self-awareness are woven into every interaction.
By using this guide to reflect on relationship-building practices, tutoring programs can ensure that relational quality remains at the center of their program design and implementation. The five pillars outlined here provide a framework for continuous improvement, allowing program leaders and tutors to assess relationship strength, avoid common pitfalls, and cultivate the kind of safe, affirming, and motivating environment where students thrive academically.
The Five Pillars of Strong Student-Tutor Relationships
Review the five pillars of strong, academically focused student-tutor relationships.
| Pillar | Actions |
| Respect | Tutors serve as the adults in the relationship. To earn students’ respect, tutors provide consistent and fair direction while valuing students’ time and effort. |
| Trust | Tutors build trust by following through on commitments and demonstrating kindness, consistency, and respect, regardless of student responses. |
| Confidence | Tutors push students to take academic risks, learn from mistakes, and achieve goals they didn’t think possible. Tutors communicate high expectations and believe in students’ potential. |
| Motivation | Tutors connect with students individually and demonstrate how learning aligns with their interests and goals. |
| Self-Awareness | Tutors help students recognize their strengths and growth areas, encouraging accountability to ambitious goals. |
Examples of Strong vs. Weak Student Relationships
Reflect on the effective student-tutor relationship practices while identifying pitfalls to avoid across the five pillars.
| Pillar | Strong | Weak |
| Respect | Tutors enforce session norms consistently, and students engage in expectations. | Tutors enforce norms inconsistently or selectively, leading to disengagement. |
| Trust | Tutors use careful language and always follow through on commitments. | Tutors say one thing but do another (e.g., promising to return to a question but never doing so). |
| Confidence | Tutors express confidence in students' abilities through words and actions. | Tutors claim to believe in students but demonstrate low expectations through their actions. |
| Motivation | Tutors connect tutoring sessions to students' goals and interests, making learning relevant. | Tutors fail to connect learning to real-world relevance or student goals, reducing engagement. |
| Self-Awareness | Tutors honestly assess student strengths and challenges, celebrating progress in actionable ways. | Tutors either ignore student progress or share feedback in dismissive or unhelpful ways. |
Evaluating Student-Tutor Relationships
Use the list of student-centered survey questions to assess the quality of student-tutor relationships. Questions can be used in surveys (Yes/No or Likert scales) to measure student experiences and reflect on opportunities to improve on these relationships over time.
| Pillar | Questions for Evaluating Student-Tutor Relationships |
| Respect |
|
| Trust |
|
| Confidence |
|
| Motivation |
|
| Self-Awareness |
|