For state and district education leaders
A clear marker of quality in tutoring program design.
The NSSA Tutoring Program Design Badge indicates how well a tutoring program’s design aligns with fundamental Tutoring Quality Standards based on provided documentation. The Badge is meant to act as a first filter to states and districts for quality to indicate that a program has a research-aligned program design.
An earned Badge means a provider’s program design is aligned with the standards.
Choosing among tutoring providers is hard when every program describes itself differently. The Badge gives you a shared, field-built yardstick for program design, so the first cut of your list rests on research.
Aligned to Tutoring Quality Standards
The Badge reflects how a provider has designed its program against a common set of quality standards
Developed and updated by the field
The standards behind the Badge come from researchers and practitioners, and they are revisited as the field learns.
Verified by a trained expert
Providers back up their self-assessment with artifacts, and an expert trained by NSSA reviews them before the Badge is awarded.
What does it tell you about a tutoring program?
- Program is deeply aware of characteristics of effective tutoring
- Program strives to align with research-backed learning
- Providers must provide documents or certify that they meet NSSA’s mostly aligned or a fully aligned criteria on over 35 indicators covering Tutor Recruitment + Selection, Tutor Preservice Training, Student-Tutor Relationship, Program Effectiveness and Improvement, Formative Assessment, Student Progress Measure, Tutor Coaching and Feedback, Tutor Consistency and Ratio, High-Quality Instructional Materials, Dosage, Setting, and Integration with School Schedule, Safety Protocols, Data Privacy and Security, Program Design, Organizational Culture
Providers are advocating for research-based practices, such as:
- At least 3 times per week for 30–60 minutes per session
- With a tutor-student ratio at 1:4 or below,
however, the provider might not implement that design at every partner site due to partner requests or constraints.
How is the Badge being used in the field?
- States and Districts use it as a screen in choosing providers
- Share the Michigan legislative inclusion
- National organizations such as the Partnership for Student Success use the Badge to understand quality as they identify participation lists
- Funders to assist in making investment decisions
What does the Badging process look like?
- Initiated by the program itself
- Pass an initial screen through taking the self-assessment
- Submit over X artifacts to support alignment to standards
- Submitted documentation will be assessed by Technical Assistance Providers (TAPs), third-party evaluators contracted by the NSSA. TAPs are education leaders and experts and are trained to use NSSA’s evaluation system to provide feedback to providers.
- In depth meeting including program leadership, TAPs and NSSA to discuss the program’s alignment to each standard and how they can improve alignment
- Based on the review of artifacts, a program either earns the Badge, or is given clear guidance on how to improve alignment to standards. The Badge is valid for three years at which time, the program must participate in the renewal process
- Total process takes approximately 8 weeks
Use the Badge to start your list.
Because every Badge holder has shown alignment with the same standards, the Badge is a strong way to create an initial list of providers you would like to partner with. It saves time and raises the floor on quality.
It is not a substitute for local judgment. Once you have a shortlist, research each provider to confirm it meets the needs of your context.
1Step one: Build your initial list with the Badge
Start with Badge holders so you know each program’s design is aligned with the field’s standards. Aware of a provider that isn’t badged? Invite them to apply. They may not have gone through the process yet.
2Step two: Research for local fit
Look closely at how each provider would work for your students, schools and community, such as the grade levels and subjects you need, capacity, staffing, data sharing, cost and references from similar partners.
Show states and districts your program is built to the standards.
Start with the self-assessment. Earn the Badge and be easier to find on the lists that decision makers build.
